Log in | Sign Up

Judge Denies Release Request for Terry Sedlacek in 2009 Pastor Fred Winters Murder Case

A Madison County hearing weighed treatment progress against safety concerns as relatives of slain Pastor Fred Winters described the lasting impact of the 2009 church attack.

Save
Listen to the story

MARYVILLE — Madison County Judge Kyle Napp denied a defense motion seeking unsupervised on-ground release and supervised off-ground release for Terry Sedlacek, who was found not guilty by reason of insanity in the 2009 murder of First Baptist Church Pastor Fred Winters.

Get The Latest News!

Don't miss our top stories and need-to-know news everyday in your inbox.

During the hearing, Sedlacek’s defense attorney argued that he has made significant progress while being housed at Alton Mental Health.

A psychologist from Alton Mental Health testified that Sedlacek has worked toward and met his treatment goals during his time at the facility.

Judge Napp questioned the psychologist about what the proposed release arrangements would look like and what safeguards would be in place.

The psychologist explained that an unsupervised on-ground release would allow Sedlacek to walk around the grounds of the mental health facility without an accompanying staff member.

Napp asked whether the grounds were surrounded by a fence. The psychologist testified that they were not and that Sedlacek could leave the fenced portion of the property. When asked what would happen if he walked away, the psychologist said security personnel would be sent to locate him.

Under the proposed supervised off-ground release, Sedlacek would be accompanied by two staff members and a driver. The psychologist testified that groups typically include four or five patients and that outings could include visits to parks, fishing locations, restaurants and an apple orchard.

Madison County Assistant State's Attorney Lauren Maricle referenced Sedlacek's progress reports during the hearing. One report, dated Sept. 16, 2026, indicated that Sedlacek was still experiencing psychosis. The doctor said he still would bark and grunt at people.

The hearing also included emotional victim impact statements from family members of Winters and one of the men injured during the attack.

Winters' wife delivered a particularly emotional statement, describing the loss of her husband just four weeks before her 40th birthday.

Article continues after sponsor message
Reach Your Local Community with Us - advertise today!

She spoke about their relationship, saying they had been together since she was 14 years old and married at a young age. She also described how much her husband loved being a pastor, adding that despite everything that happened, she would not change their life together.

One of the men stabbed during the attack also addressed the court. He told the court that he still wonders why he is alive and Pastor Fred Winters is not.

He also said this was the sixth time he had been required to relive the events of that day in court.

Impact statements written by both of Winters' daughters were also read during the hearing.

The 2009 Church Shooting

Sedlacek was 33 years old when he entered First Baptist Church in Maryville on March 8, 2009, during a Sunday worship service.

As Pastor Fred Winters delivered his sermon, Sedlacek walked down the main aisle, pulled out a .45-caliber handgun and opened fire on the pastor.

Parishioners attempted to stop Sedlacek, who was also armed with a knife. During the struggle, he stabbed two men before attempting to take his own life by cutting his throat.

Winters died from gunshot wounds to his chest and abdomen. The two men who were stabbed survived their injuries.

Sedlacek was charged the following day with first-degree murder and aggravated battery. In 2015, he was found not guilty by reason of insanity.

Investigators determined that Sedlacek was not a member of First Baptist Church and did not know Winters.

Judge Napp ultimately denied the defense request for both unsupervised on-ground release and supervised off-ground release.

More like this:

Man Who Killed Maryville Pastor Requests Supervised Outings
Yesterday
Three Injured in Warrenton Middle School Stabbing, Student Arrested
4 days ago
Austin Mullins Sentenced to 32 Years in Wood River Killing
Jun 29, 2026
Haine Announces 25-Year Prison Term For Granite City Man Convicted Of Felony Sex Offenses
Jul 31, 2026
New Program at Edwardsville Elementary School Helps Students Regulate Emotions
Oct 22, 2026